Dear Kara, thank you for your feedback — I’m sorry that the Jade Gua Sha you received felt thinner than expected. Our tools are handcrafted from natural Xiuyan jade, so each piece is unique and can vary slightly in thickness and weight. I personally prefer the thinner tools, and many of our customers do as well, as they tend to glide more easily over the facial contours — but we completely understand your preference for a sturdier feel. We’ll send you a thicker Jade Gua Sha as a complimentary replacement right away. Thank you again for letting us know.